William Bole

Journalist, Author, Analyst

  • Home
  • Books
  • Articles
    • Religion, Culture & Politics
    • Education & Intellectual Life
    • Business and Leadership
  • TheoPol Blog
    • Latest Posts
    • Economics
    • Politics
    • International Affairs
    • Education
    • Culture
    • Race
    • Poverty
    • Religion
  • Profile
  • Contact
  • May 12, 2025

The Gods of Keynes

October 13, 2011 by William Bole Leave a Comment

It has been said that economists are people who work with numbers but don’t have the personality to be accountants. One number-cruncher who put the lie to this witticism was John Maynard Keynes (1883-1946), who had the personality of a rock star. He was given to grand pronouncements, as when he wrote a letter to his friend George Bernard Shaw, in 1935, predicting—correctly—that the book he was writing would “largely revolutionize the way people think about economic problems.”

In an illuminating essay in the October 10 New Yorker, John Cassidy teased out the man’s paradoxes in both life and thought. As a young economist with the British government, Keynes had numerous affairs with men before settling down happily with a Russian ballerina. Today he is disparaged by many conservatives as a “socialist,” but he was always a creature of the ruling class. During the Great Depression he declared that when the proletariat revolts, he will stand proudly with the “educated bourgeoisie.”

Keynes applauded what he called “the animal spirits,” the drive to invest and reap wealth. But he pointed out that these instincts are dimmed in a slumberous economy, and his theory—radical at the time—was that the government had to step in “to revive the animal spirits and jolt an economy out of its rut” by way of deficit spending, as Cassidy explains. And so, with his 1936 book The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money, Keynes upended economic policymaking.

Through the decades, deficit spending proved an effective treatment for economic dispiritedness (though Keynes felt the medicine should be applied primarily when the economy is bedridden). He became the intellectual godparent of what is now provocatively known as stimulus spending.

Keynes and the Theologians

There’s much in Keynesian theory that jibes with faith-based reflections on the economy, and much that is, characteristically, paradoxical in that light.

For one thing, it would be hard to find a religious tradition that seriously doubts government’s inescapable role in fostering economic wellbeing. “Indeed, the whole reason for the existence of civil authorities is the realization of the common good,” Pope John XXIII wrote in his 1963 encyclical letter Pacem in Terris.

Different faith groups may tint this teaching in different ways. Catholic social theorists, for example, tend to speak confidently of the virtues of government, the positive good it plays in promoting human dignity and economic justice. Protestant social ethicists might at times look at government more strictly as a necessity than a blessing, a countervailing force against the abuses of wealth (just as private power is such a force against overreaching government). Neither tradition would cheer Rick Perry’s recent campaign promise to make government “as inconsequential as possible” in our lives.

There’s another side of Keynes that’s seldom noted. Unlike many in his tribe, he believed that economics had a purpose beyond economics (beyond, for example, increasing aggregate demand, the goal for which he’s famous). He argued that the ultimate aim of economic activity was to contribute to “the good life,” as Robert Skidelsky relates in his engaging 2009 book Keynes: The Return of the Master. Keynes was speaking generally in the ethical sense of being a good person; he lamented greed in that context. The theologians would agree.

But here comes another Keynesian paradox. He pronounced that the world was not ready for an ethical economy and probably would not be for quite some time until there’s great abundance.

For at least another hundred years we must pretend to ourselves and to everyone that fair is foul and foul is fair; for foul is useful and fair is not. Avarice and usury and precaution must be our gods for a little longer still. For only they can lead us out of the tunnel of economic necessity into daylight.

In other words, for all practical purposes greed is good until the far-off day when it isn’t. The animal spirits will have to remain higher on the ontological food chain than the human spirit; the economy will have to proceed in a moral vacuum. This would be the breaking point between Keynes and the theologians. The latter would say the good economy is not utopian. It’s one that helps people today become “dignified participants in their community,” as the brilliant evangelical Protestant theologian Ronald Sider has framed it.

Greed is not very dignified, from that perspective. Neither is a person’s lack of minimum social goods (to borrow a phrase from Catholic social thought) such as a decent income and affordable access to healthcare. The faith-based question is how to deliver those goods in the here and now. And this brings us back, with a touch more paradox, to the government’s role in reviving the animal spirits. It winds back to stimulus.

Keynes himself was a jocular atheist who would have probably laughed the social-justice reverends out of the room. All the same, he ushered in the Keynesian tools that in hard times past have made the faith-based vision seem a little less distant. …read more

Filed Under: Economics, Selected, TheoPol Blog Tagged With: catholic social teaching, economic justice, john maynard keynes, religion and politics, social ethics

The Life of Meaning

Reflections on Faith, Doubt, and Repairing the World

By Bob Abernethy and William Bole, with a Foreword by Tom Brokaw

Nautilus Book Awards
Gold Winner 2008

About William Bole

William Bole is a writer with a background in both daily journalism and academia. He writes at the three-way intersection of religion, public affairs, and the arts, while often steering into other areas of interest, especially higher education and management. In addition, he teaches nonfiction writing at Boston College, where he serves primarily as director of communications at the Carroll School of Management. … read more

About TheoPol

Welcome to TheoPol—a writing project that ran for four years. During much of that time, it featured weekly snapshots of interconnections between theology and politics. The questions—as to what these connections are, or should be, and whether there should be any at all—remain current. ...read more

Reviews

"A thoughtful new blog"
— Bill Tammeus, Faith Matters
>> read the review.

“A great gift for relating [ideas] with a storyteller’s instinct and wit.”
— Tom Roberts, National Catholic Reporter
>> read the review.

Selected TheoPol Posts

Selma, the Sequel

Of Martyrs and Murderers

Why Mandela Forgave the Butchers

Lascivious Swedes and other Vindications of Calvin

Sacred Space, at the Corner of Boylston and Berkeley

“What the Hell’s the Presidency for?”

When MLK was Old

Heschel’s Prophets, and Ours

Even Less Moral

Last Rites for Capital Punishment?

Friending Aristotle

The Man who Discovered Poverty

The Exceptional American

Quantifying the Unquantifiable

The Gods of Keynes

“The Beloved Community”: A Pulse Check

A Theology of Embarrassment

Archives

  • September 2021
  • March 2021
  • July 2020
  • June 2015
  • March 2015
  • January 2015
  • November 2014
  • October 2014
  • January 2014
  • December 2013
  • November 2013
  • October 2013
  • September 2013
  • August 2013
  • June 2013
  • May 2013
  • April 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013
  • December 2012
  • November 2012
  • October 2012
  • September 2012
  • August 2012
  • July 2012
  • June 2012
  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • March 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • September 2011
  • August 2011
The Idea Hunter

The Idea Hunter

Organized Labor and the Church

Reflections of a “Labor Priest”

Forgiveness in International Politics

Forgiveness in International Politics

Copyright © 2025 William Bole
PH: 978.475.2474
Email: info@WilliamBole.com

Site design by: Blue Iris Webdesign